A better-than-the-box lemon icebox pie - WSFA.com Montgomery Alabama news.

A better-than-the-box lemon icebox pie

Updated: Sep 29, 2011 04:01 PM EDT
© Anna Stockwell / Bonnier © Anna Stockwell / Bonnier


By Judy Haubert


Last summer, my client's teenage daughter went through a lemon phase and, as their private chef, I could barely make enough lemony desserts to keep up with her interest.

I was desperately searching for new ideas when I stumbled upon a package of dairy-free whipped topping that promoted a recipe for lemon pie using frozen lemonade concentrate and a purchased graham cracker crust. 

Chicken recipes at Saveur»

It turned out surprisingly well, but I felt more than a little guilty using such blatant store-bought shortcuts. After all, I was being paid for my cooking prowess, and the recipe required none.

I figured there was a more authentic approach to such a crowd pleaser, and ultimately couldn't abide the sight of serving anything in that purchased foil pie tin.

16 easy casseroles at Saveur»

A whole year passed before I got around to updating the recipe, replacing the frozen non-dairy topping with real whipped cream, and making my own lemon simple syrup as a stand-in for the lemonade.

The store-bought graham crust was usurped by a self-assembled one using vanilla shortbread, and the addition of homemade candied lemon peel scattered over the top of the pie elevated this dessert into company status. 

The Saveur 100: Recipes and techniques» 

I made the new version for my client's daughter recently, the creamy slices of lemon mousse melting into crisp golden crust on a twilit late-summer evening.

The back-of-the-box version from the summer before hadn't given rise to such oohs and ahhs before digging in; the extra time and effort was worth it.



See the recipe for Lemon Icebox Pie »

 

© 2012 SAVEUR
All rights reserved.
  • Mark Leslie RecipesMore>>

  • Leslie Bailey's “A Top of the Morning Breakfast For St. Paddy's Day!”

    Leslie Bailey's “A Top of the Morning Breakfast For St. Paddy's Day!”

    Wednesday, March 12 2014 2:03 PM EDT2014-03-12 18:03:49 GMT
    Wsfa recipe for wed march 22,2014 "A Top of the Morning Breakfast for St. Paddy's Day!" 1 container of Bisquick pancake mix cooked bacon strips green food coloring butter softened powdered sugar Directions: MakeMore >>

    WSFA 12 News Alabama Live recipe for Wednesday March 22,2014. "A Top of the Morning Breakfast for St. Paddy's Day!"More >>

  • Mark Leslie's Quick Pickled Vegetable Platter

    Mark Leslie's Quick Pickled Vegetable Platter

    Friday, May 31 2013 3:31 PM EDT2013-05-31 19:31:06 GMT
    Making pickles doesn't mean having to pull out the dill and canning gear to spend a day over a hot stove. With a little notice ahead, I use salt and vinegar to quickly pickle vegetables from my gardenMore >>
    Making pickles doesn't mean having to pull out the dill and canning gear to spend a day over a hot stove. With a little notice ahead, I use salt and vinegar to quickly pickle vegetables from my gardenMore >>
  • Mark Leslie's "Old School BLT"

    Mark Leslie's "Old School BLT"

    Friday, May 24 2013 3:47 PM EDT2013-05-24 19:47:32 GMT
    Before the microwave, turkey bacon, pre-sliced loaf bread and store-bought mayo, the wholesome BLT had more character. A staple for a simple and refreshing meal on a hot summer's day, my twist on thisMore >>
    Before the microwave, turkey bacon, pre-sliced loaf bread and store-bought mayo, the wholesome BLT had more character. A staple for a simple and refreshing meal on a hot summer's day, my twist on this American favorite...More >>
*DISCLAIMER*: The information contained in or provided through this site section is intended for general consumer understanding and education only and is not intended to be and is not a substitute for professional advice. Use of this site section and any information contained on or provided through this site section is at your own risk and any information contained on or provided through this site section is provided on an "as is" basis without any representations or warranties.
Powered by WorldNow