Guest Editorial: "SCOTUS could go either way on Section 5" - WSFA.com: News Weather and Sports for Montgomery, AL.

Guest Editorial: "SCOTUS could go either way on Section 5"

Posted: Updated:
  • EditorialsMore>>

  • Editorial: "Hands Off!"

    Editorial: "Hands Off!"

    Thursday, April 17 2014 7:20 PM EDT2014-04-17 23:20:14 GMT
    Hands off!  That's what every parent of a student wants to say to a teacher, coach or substitute teacher with desires other than educational, related to our children.  This year alone in our area a femaleMore >>
    Hands off!  That's what every parent of a student wants to say to a teacher, coach or substitute teacher with desires other than educational, related to our children.More >>
  • Editorial: "Triumph and Conquest"

    Editorial: "Triumph and Conquest"

    Tuesday, April 15 2014 7:20 PM EDT2014-04-15 23:20:09 GMT
    This week marks the one year anniversary of the Boston Marathon bombings; bombings that claimed the lives of four and injured more than 260 people.  A year ago this week was to be a day of triumph andMore >>
    This week marks the one year anniversary of the Boston Marathon bombings; bombings that claimed the lives of four and injured more than 260 people.  A year ago this week was to be a day of triumph andMore >>
  • Editorial: "Money is Power"

    Editorial: "Money is Power"

    Thursday, April 10 2014 7:20 PM EDT2014-04-10 23:20:06 GMT
    Last week the Supreme Court struck down overall limits individuals can contribute to candidates and political committees during a two-year federal election cycle now. The ruling resulted in a divided Supreme CourtMore >>
    Last week the Supreme Court struck down overall limits individuals can contribute to candidates and political committees during a two-year federal election cycle now. The ruling resulted in a divided Supreme CourtMore >>
  • Editorials 2013More>>

  • Editorial: Happy Holidays

    Editorial: Happy Holidays

    Tuesday, December 24 2013 7:15 PM EST2013-12-25 00:15:09 GMT
    Happy Holidays! When I say Happy Holidays to some people they think I am ignoring Christmas and trying to just be politically correct. That couldn't be any further from the truth. I really mean Happy HolidaysMore >>
    Happy Holidays! When I say Happy Holidays to some people they think I am ignoring Christmas and trying to just be politically correct. That couldn't be any further from the truth. I really mean Happy Holidays and that certainly includes Christmas.More >>
  • Editorial "Viewer Feedback: End the Conversation/Gambling"

    Editorial "Viewer Feedback: End the Conversation/Gambling"

    Thursday, December 19 2013 7:20 PM EST2013-12-20 00:20:06 GMT
    Our editorial earlier this week asking our legislators to again allow Alabamians to vote "yes" or "no" on legalized gaming elicited the following feedback via emails received and comments on wsfa.com andMore >>
    Our editorial earlier this week asking our legislators to again allow Alabamians to vote "yes" or "no" on legalized gaming elicited the following feedback via emails received and comments on wsfa.com andMore >>
  • Editorial: "End the Conversation"

    Editorial: "End the Conversation"

    Tuesday, December 17 2013 7:20 PM EST2013-12-18 00:20:09 GMT
    What do you say we end the conversation once and for all on legalizing gambling in Alabama and pass legislation next year to let the people of Alabama vote and gamble if they so desire?  This week marksMore >>
    What do you say we end the conversation once and for all on legalizing gambling in Alabama and pass legislation next year to let the people of Alabama vote and gamble if they so desire?  This week marksMore >>
MONTGOMERY, AL (WSFA) -

The U. S. Supreme Court is expected to rule as soon as Thursday on a suit filed by Shelby County to strike down Section 5 of the 1965 Voting Rights Act.

Section 5 requires that the Justice Department pre-approve any changes in districting or voting laws in a number of primarily southern states.

Some pundits argue that Section 5 has come to be used more as a tool to ensure minority populations in legislative bodies, than a way to tackle ballot box issues.

In oral arguments at the end of April, Justice Scalia agreed, saying that Section 5 perpetuates racial entitlement.

Chief Justice Roberts questioned the law on the presumption of regional racism,  and Kennedy, the swing Justice on the court,  questioned Section 5 based purely on federalism grounds.

The point is that, even though Congress overwhelmingly renewed the Voting Rights act for 25 year in 2006, this Supreme Court decision could go either way.

If Shelby County loses we will have Section 5 as law for another 18 years, and the  image of a racially charged South will continue, warranted or not.

More importantly, if Section 5 is stricken, the question becomes  "Have we progressed far enough so that we no longer need a Section 5 to ensure fairness  in the voting process?" 

I'd like to think we have, and I hope so. 

Copyright 2013 WSFA 12 News.  All rights reserved.

  • Guest Editorial: "SCOTUS could go either way on Section 5"More>>

  • Voting Rights Act

    Voting Rights Act

    As the U. S. Supreme Court prepares to make a decision on the case involving Shelby County and the Voting Rights Act, we have gathered a number of stories from the past months concerning the issue.  We will have complete breaking news coverage of the decision when it is announced.More >>
Powered by WorldNow