State responds to Hubbard motion to compel Brady production

State responds to Hubbard motion to compel Brady production

OPELIKA, AL (WSFA) - The State of Alabama is issuing a formal response to Alabama House Speaker Mike Hubbard's defense team which sought to compel the prosecution to release exculpatory material, or evidence from the state that would benefit the defense, as required by Brady v. Maryland.

The State's 27 page filing, issued on March 31, states that "Hubbard has failed to identify any alleged exculpatory material that has not been produced..." and that "Hubbard improperly seeks to obtain the State's work product and has failed to show either necessity or bad faith to overcome the presumption that the State has no obligation..." to turn over that material to the defense.

"Hubbard is not entitled to have the State provide him a roadmap of its mental impressions and legal theories regarding how the evidence against him fits together for purposes of trial," the State said. "Hubbard has his own attorneys and consultants to review the evidence and make that determination themselves."

The Hubbard defense team has not yet publicly reacted to the State's response.

In addition to this motion, the Hubbard defense team is seeking case dismissal on the grounds of prosecutorial misconduct.

Hubbard's trial is currently scheduled to begin on October 19, 2015.

Copyright 2015 WSFA 12 News. All rights reserved.