Ken Hare In Depth: Sealing public records must never be done lig - WSFA.com Montgomery Alabama news.

opinion

Ken Hare In Depth: Sealing public records must never be done lightly

  • THE GREAT OUTDOORSKen Hare's Natural AlabamaMore>>

  • Special

    Ken Hare's Natural Alabama: Birding road trips are also about freedom

    Ken Hare's Natural Alabama: Birding road trips are also about freedom

    Saturday, May 20 2017 2:30 PM EDT2017-05-20 18:30:36 GMT
    Purple Gallinule in Geneva County. (Source: Ken Hare)Purple Gallinule in Geneva County. (Source: Ken Hare)

    I love road trips. There is something soul-satisfying about jumping into a car and heading out with only a general idea of where you're going and what you're going to do.

    More >>

    I love road trips. There is something soul-satisfying about jumping into a car and heading out with only a general idea of where you're going and what you're going to do.

    More >>
  • Special

    Ken Hare's Natural Alabama: Sometimes weather good for birds, but not birding

    Ken Hare's Natural Alabama: Sometimes weather good for birds, but not birding

    Saturday, May 6 2017 11:45 AM EDT2017-05-06 15:45:34 GMT
    AOS members, never without their binoculars, at the Goat Trees in Dauphin Island. (Photo Ken Hare)AOS members, never without their binoculars, at the Goat Trees in Dauphin Island. (Photo Ken Hare)

    Sometimes, what's good for the birds might not be good for the birders. Each year, the Alabama Ornithological Society holds two of its three meetings on Dauphin Island specifically to try to be there when migrating birds are making stopovers during their spring and fall flights to and from wintering grounds in the Caribbean, South America and Central America. But when about 100 AOS members gathered for three days of field trips in April, there were far fewer migrants than are usuall...

    More >>

    Sometimes, what's good for the birds might not be good for the birders. Each year, the Alabama Ornithological Society holds two of its three meetings on Dauphin Island specifically to try to be there when migrating birds are making stopovers during their spring and fall flights to and from wintering grounds in the Caribbean, South America and Central America. But when about 100 AOS members gathered for three days of field trips in April, there were far fewer migrants than are usuall...

    More >>
  • Ken Hare's Natural Alabama

    Ken Hare's Natural Alabama: New bird banding project builds on years of research

    Ken Hare's Natural Alabama: New bird banding project builds on years of research

    Saturday, April 29 2017 5:02 PM EDT2017-04-29 21:02:35 GMT
    Mist nets such as this one are used to harmlessly catch small birds such as this Common Yellowthroat Warbler. (Photo Ken Hare)Mist nets such as this one are used to harmlessly catch small birds such as this Common Yellowthroat Warbler. (Photo Ken Hare)

    For more than two decades starting in 1989, ornithologists captured and banded thousands of birds migrating through the Fort Morgan peninsula on Alabama's coastline. 

    More >>

    For more than two decades starting in 1989, ornithologists captured and banded thousands of birds migrating through the Fort Morgan peninsula on Alabama's coastline. 

    More >>
MONTGOMERY, AL (WSFA) -

When the details broke this week about Gov. Robert Bentley's divorce settlement being unsealed, a reporter working on the story told me, "This kind of reporting makes me feel a little dirty."

Welcome to the club. That's the way lots of journalists I have known over the years felt when circumstances put them in the position of having to report about the personal lives of political figures. 

Sadly, however, sometimes such reporting is often necessary.

By now, those readers who are interested know the who-got-what details in the governor's divorce filings.   But the filings do not contain what several news organizations -- including WSFA -- were looking for when they took court action to have the filings unsealed -- indications of whether the circumstances leading up to the divorce involved actions that might reflect on or affect Bentley's performance of his duties as governor.

To their credit, Bentley and Dianne Bentley both finally did the right thing and asked that the documents be unsealed.

[DOCUMENTSBentley divorce finalized (.pdf)]

[DOCUMENTSBentley divorce settlement details (.pdf)]

But they never should have been sealed in the first place.  While Alabama judges have the right to seal divorce cases in certain situations, it is a step that should be taken only in rare circumstances, and not when it involves high profile elected or appointed officials.

According to court officials, only about one-half of 1 percent of divorce cases in Alabama in 2014 were sealed. 

Actually, the Bentleys' original request to have the divorce proceedings sealed may have contained one of the best arguments for making them public. According to the motion to seal, “the defendant holds a prominent office in the state of Alabama, and it would be in the parties’ best interest that the public not be able to access the record in this divorce action.”  

If the governor originally claimed that his "prominent office" was a reason to seal the record, how could he later claim that this was purely a personal issue? He couldn't logically have it both ways. 

In addition, the sealing of the records simply fueled the rumors that have been swirling around Bentley for the past few months. If the governor thought sealing the records would tamp down the rumor mill, he was wrong; it had just the opposite effect.

Perhaps the governor and Dianne Bentley finally realized that sealing the record was making matters worse, not better. Whatever their reasons, we applaud them for finally doing the right thing.

Alabamians should hope that the state's judges will learn from this case as well. The public has a right to know what goes on in their court system, and the presumption should always be on the side of openness. Sealing court records -- even divorce cases -- should be done only in rare situations where the circumstances clearly and overwhelmingly outweigh the public's right to know how government and the courts operate.

Finally, and most importantly, the fact that a party to a legal action "holds a prominent office" should never be a reason for judges to seal court records. Instead, it is one more among many reasons for judges to keep court records open to the public.

Ken Hare is a veteran newspaper editorial page editor and editorial writer who now writes a regular column for wsfa.com. Feedback appreciated at khare@wsfa.com

Copyright 2015 WSFA 12 News. All rights reserved.

Powered by Frankly