Bill advances to take away AL judges' ability to override juries - WSFA.com Montgomery Alabama news.

Bill advances to take away AL judges' ability to override juries

(Source: WSFA 12 News) (Source: WSFA 12 News)
MONTGOMERY, AL (WSFA) -

Alabama is now the only state in the country with a judicial override law, but that could soon come to an end. Judicial override allows judges to overturn a jury's verdict in a capital murder case from their recommendation of life without the possibility of parole to the death penalty, or the opposite.

Thursday a bill passed out of the Senate to end this controversial practice. 

According to the Equal Justice Initiative, 20 percent of the inmates on death row in Alabama were sentenced to death by a judicial override, meaning a jury returned a sentence of life without the possibility of parole and the judge overturned that decision and sentenced the person to death.

Sen. Dick Brewbaker, R- Montgomery, calls judicial override a moral issue, something he’s working to end with SB16.

“One of the most important things about our democracy is our laws are derived from the common law," Brewbaker said. “That’s why a crime of violence is a crime against a community. That’s why we have a trial in the community. That’s why we pick a jury of the community and they decide guilt, innocence, and punishment. Judicial override flies in the face of that. You are entitled to a trial of a jury of your peers, and that ought to apply to sentencing too.”

Brewbaker’s bill would allow juries to hand down the death sentence in a 10-12 vote. The House version of the bill, HB32, sponsored by Rep. Chris England, D- Montgomery, would require a unanimous vote by a jury to hand down the death penalty.

“Whether we pass my bill, or bring England’s up here, we are going to pass one of those bills," Brewbaker said. 

The Alabama Bar Association supports ending judicial override and Brewbaker says judges are in support too. Many believe judicial override injects politics into the death penalty. Circuit judges are elected, and some numbers show overrides are higher during election years.

“It taints the process," Brewbaker said. “I did not have a single judge talk to me formally or informally say we need to keep judicial override. They were very frank in saying it's used to pressure them during election years.”

Sen. Tripp Pittman, R- Montgomery, was the sole no vote on SB16 and added an amendment to make clear SB16 was not retroactive. 

“I think it’s appropriate for judges to have that discretion," Pittman explained. “With the complexity of certain trials and the heinous nature of some crimes, the judge needs that discretion and support them having that. I have confidence in all situations they will use that discretion properly.

The House is expected to vote on HB32 next week.

Copyright 2017 WSFA 12 News. All rights reserved.

  • Political Stories from the Associated PressMore>>

  • Trump, GOP to huddle as outrage builds over border policy

    Trump, GOP to huddle as outrage builds over border policy

    Tuesday, June 19 2018 1:10 AM EDT2018-06-19 05:10:31 GMT
    Tuesday, June 19 2018 2:50 AM EDT2018-06-19 06:50:48 GMT
    (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite). The Capitol is seen in Washington, Friday, June 15, 2018. Calls are mounting on Capitol Hill for the Trump administration to end the separation of families at the southern border ahead of a visit from President Donald Tr...(AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite). The Capitol is seen in Washington, Friday, June 15, 2018. Calls are mounting on Capitol Hill for the Trump administration to end the separation of families at the southern border ahead of a visit from President Donald Tr...

    Calls are mounting for President Trump to end family separations at the border ahead of a meeting with House Republicans.

    More >>

    Calls are mounting for President Trump to end family separations at the border ahead of a meeting with House Republicans.

    More >>
  • High court decision extends legal battle over gerrymandering

    High court decision extends legal battle over gerrymandering

    Tuesday, June 19 2018 12:50 AM EDT2018-06-19 04:50:31 GMT
    Tuesday, June 19 2018 2:50 AM EDT2018-06-19 06:50:39 GMT
    The Supreme Court's decision to avoid a definitive ruling about partisan gerrymandering shifts the focus to other states, most notably North Carolina.More >>
    The Supreme Court's decision to avoid a definitive ruling about partisan gerrymandering shifts the focus to other states, most notably North Carolina.More >>
  • 'Papa! Papa!' Audio of children stokes rage over separation

    'Papa! Papa!' Audio of children stokes rage over separation

    Tuesday, June 19 2018 1:20 AM EDT2018-06-19 05:20:32 GMT
    Tuesday, June 19 2018 2:50 AM EDT2018-06-19 06:50:37 GMT
    (U.S. Customs and Border Protection's Rio Grande Valley Sector via AP). In this photo provided by U.S. Customs and Border Protection, a U.S. Border Patrol agent watches as people who've been taken into custody related to cases of illegal entry into the...(U.S. Customs and Border Protection's Rio Grande Valley Sector via AP). In this photo provided by U.S. Customs and Border Protection, a U.S. Border Patrol agent watches as people who've been taken into custody related to cases of illegal entry into the...
    An audio recording that appears to capture the heartbreaking cries of small Spanish-speaking children being processed by U.S. officials stoked the uproar over the policy of separating immigrant children from their...More >>
    An audio recording that appears to capture the heartbreaking cries of small Spanish-speaking children being processed by U.S. officials stoked the uproar over the policy of separating immigrant children from their parents.More >>
  • ElectionDecision 2018More>>

  • Maddox wants to debate Ivey in governor's race

    Maddox wants to debate Ivey in governor's race

    Wednesday, June 13 2018 3:18 PM EDT2018-06-13 19:18:31 GMT
    Democratic candidate for governor Walt Maddox wants to debate incumbent Gov. Kay Ivey ahead of the November election. (Source: WSFA 12 News)Democratic candidate for governor Walt Maddox wants to debate incumbent Gov. Kay Ivey ahead of the November election. (Source: WSFA 12 News)

    Democratic candidate for governor Walt Maddox wants to debate incumbent Gov. Kay Ivey ahead of the November election.

    More >>

    Democratic candidate for governor Walt Maddox wants to debate incumbent Gov. Kay Ivey ahead of the November election.

    More >>
  • Races in Alabama's July 17 primary run-off elections

    Races in Alabama's July 17 primary run-off elections

    Wednesday, June 13 2018 2:00 PM EDT2018-06-13 18:00:32 GMT

    Alabamians headed to the polls on June 5 to fill out their choices in the state's primaries. But some of those races aren't a done deal. They'll need citizens to head back to the ballot box on July 17 to pick the winner of several run-off elections.

    More >>

    Alabamians headed to the polls on June 5 to fill out their choices in the state's primaries. But some of those races aren't a done deal. They'll need citizens to head back to the ballot box on July 17 to pick the winner of several run-off elections.

    More >>
  • King, Marshall trade swipes as AL AG primary run-off continues

    King, Marshall trade swipes as AL AG primary run-off continues

    Monday, June 11 2018 1:25 PM EDT2018-06-11 17:25:43 GMT
    King held a press conference Monday morning. (Source: WSFA 12 News)King held a press conference Monday morning. (Source: WSFA 12 News)

    Former Alabama Attorney General Troy King is fighting to get his old job back, but current AG Steve Marshall isn't going to make it easy.

    More >>

    Former Alabama Attorney General Troy King is fighting to get his old job back, but current AG Steve Marshall isn't going to make it easy.

    More >>
Powered by Frankly