MONTGOMERY, AL (WSFA) - Interim State Superintendent Dr. Ed Richardson is preparing to slash positions and close several schools. He revealed his plan Friday in an hour-long update on the state's intervention of the Montgomery Public School System.
"Alabama has 137 school systems. There's only one under state intervention: Montgomery," Richardson said in his opening remarks. "I think the time for platitudes and excuses are over."
Richardson was blunt and methodical, and let it be known who and what he believes put the school system in its current situation.
"I frequently hear from those in leadership positions that it's all about the children, and I say bologna. It's all about the inconvenience to adults, and student interests are a distant second. The results speak for themselves," Richardson said.
The superintendent said both the Montgomery Public School Board and the State Department of Education hold some blame.
"For the past three months, I've been in damage control mode trying to correct some issues. The first side of that was because it became clear to me that the Montgomery Board of Education refused to recognize the magnitude of the problem and would not take ownership of those problems," Richardson said.
"And the second reason was this department of education, that attempted to intervene in a rather ill-conceived manner which contributed to a number of problems," he continued. One issue he addressed was the state giving nearly $1.5 million in funding to Pike Road Schools that should have gone to MPS, an issue he said was being addressed.
Richardson said his plan to improve system finances is "not going to be easy" as he shared details.
"We want to stay out of the classrooms until the very last," Richardson said of cuts, "because if we're going to make improvements in student achievement, we're going to have to have some good teachers and principals out there."
The plan goes as follows:
- 17 central office positions cut - A savings of $1.1 million.
- All travel costs for school board members cut - A savings of $51,133.
- Closing four schools: Floyd Elementary, Chisholm Elementary, Dozier Elementary and Georgia Washington Middle staring with 2018-19. These closures give MPS an estimated saving of $1.4 million.
- All unused school system properties will be put up for sale.
- All nine central office buildings will be closed for next school year and be put up for sale.
- Georgia Washington Middle School will be sold to the Pike Road School System for $9.75 million. MPS will also receive the $1.5 million that was accidentally given to Pike Road Schools. PRS will pay everything upon the sale closing, not in spread out payments.
- Floyd Middle Magnet School will move to the old Houston Hills Junior High building.
The sale of the historic Georgia Washington school has been controversial. The deal fell through once, but Richardson said the school must be sold to prevent hundreds of MPS teachers from being fired.
Richardson said public hearings will be held on the school closings and there will be revised attendance zones and bus routes.
"It's been my experience and belief that students will rise to the level of expectations..." Richardson said. "I believe the students in Montgomery are just as capable as anybody else's, even though when you look at these scores you would have to wonder," he added.
Recent statewide report cards for every school system and each individual school found MPS with an overall D score and 11 failing schools, about 15 percent of all those failing in Alabama.
Richardson called the failure rate "an embarrassing situation" and said "we can't live with that."
The intervention report found that after the since-canceled ACT Aspire test was given to students last year in Grades 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 10, only 27 percent of Montgomery students rated proficient compared to 41 percent statewide. The numbers fall even more when taking magnet schools out of the equation.
"Let me just put it all out here. Alabama's state scores are embarrassing low. We're among the bottom in the United States, and I hope we can't stand that either. But if you're low in one of the bottom states, that should convey to you the problem that lies before us," Richardson explained.
He listed the 10th grade proficiency rates for each of the city's traditional high schools and each had "startling" rates. For math, Richarson pointed out Lee High, where he did his own chemistry internship, has just over 1 percent of 10th graders considered proficient.
When he read figures on the gap between graduation rates and the percentage of students who are college and career ready, he asked an educator what the large divide between the two numbers could possibly mean. Without hesitating, Richardson said the educator responded "diploma mill."
For instance, the Montgomery County system had a 2015-16 graduation rate of 78 percent, yet just 43 percent were rated as ready for college or a career.
"I would say, very frankly, it is deceptive and intellectually dishonest to allow students to graduate from high school with unacceptably low levels," Richardson assessed.
Richardson also spoke on the system's chronic absentee rates. Lanier High School, for example, has a stunning 37 percent of students who have been absent more than 15 days in the school year.
"This is something that can be solved," Richardson said, "and it is a major factor contributing one, to our low achievement scores, but more importantly it's saying this school has not been administered in a way to consider the student's best interest."
Richardson announced an action plan to improve student achievement. The five-year plan includes:
- Opening an alternative school for disruptive and threatening students at Mcintyre Middle School, which is currently closed.
- A complete evaluation of all principals. Those not performing at a high level will be removed.
- Tests in 5th and 8th grades to see if reading and math scores are below acceptable levels. Teachers, parents and students will be informed.
- Relationships with parents need to improve.
- Richardson has received a letter of intent to start 4 to 5 charter schools within MPS. Once an official application is received, if National Association Charter School Authorizers approves, Richardson will approve them.
- These charter schools would be required to take all students zoned to them and will receive the same amount of funding as others schools.
- Richardson will receive all non-magnet high schools to determine if they need reconstitution, including firing certified employees and replacing principals.
Montgomery Mayor Todd Strange released this statement:
The Montgomery County Commission released this statement:
DR. RICHARDSON'S FULL PRESENTATION