WASHINGTON (AP)-- A divided Supreme Court today is sidestepping a challenge to Bush administration wartime detention powers by rejecting an appeal from a man held until recently as an enemy combatant without traditional legal rights.
Jose Padilla was moved in January to Miami to face criminal charges, and the government argued that the appeal over his indefinite detention was now pointless.
Three justices said the court should have agreed to take up the case anyway: Justices David H. Souter, Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Stephen Breyer.
An appeals court panel had all but called for the court to deal with the case, saying it was troubled by the Bush administration's change in legal strategy — after holding Padilla more than three years without charges.
Justices first considered in 2004 whether Padilla's constitutional rights were violated when he was detained as an “enemy combatant” without charges and access to a lawyer. Justices dodged a decision on technical grounds. In a dissent Justice John Paul Stevens said then that "at stake in this case is nothing less than the essence of a free society."
The jury in Bill Cosby's sexual assault retrial has reached a verdict: guilty on all counts.
More >>The jury in Bill Cosby's sexual assault retrial has reached a verdict: guilty on all counts.
More >>The suspected Golden State Killer became less prolific but deadlier after losing his job as a police officer.
More >>The suspected Golden State Killer became less prolific but deadlier after losing his job as a police officer.
More >>Over the next few years, the automaker will cut its North America passenger car lineup by more than 80 percent.
More >>Over the next few years, the automaker will cut its North America passenger car lineup by more than 80 percent.
More >>Police said a 911 caller thought he saw the body of Tyrell Holmes crawling on the ground while still on fire. Holmes died from smoke inhalation, thermal injuries and stab wounds.
More >>Police said a 911 caller thought he saw the body of Tyrell Holmes crawling on the ground while still on fire. Holmes died from smoke inhalation, thermal injuries and stab wounds.
More >>Forrest Hunter wanted to buy a hunting license and was tired of waiting for help.
More >>Forrest Hunter wanted to buy a hunting license and was tired of waiting for help.
More >>Groups have gone through the exhibit throughout the day, leaving very emotional- using words like, "heavy" and "overwhelmed"; many leaving in tears.
More >>Groups have gone through the exhibit throughout the day, leaving very emotional- using words like, "heavy" and "overwhelmed"; many leaving in tears.
More >>A student is charged with having a weapon on campus at a school in Montgomery.
More >>A student is charged with having a weapon on campus at a school in Montgomery.
More >>A mother and daughter had a heartwarming reunion Thursday morning after more than a year apart.
More >>A mother and daughter had a heartwarming reunion Thursday morning after more than a year apart.
More >>Showers and thunderstorms will overspread the area from west to east this morning as our next storm system approaches.
More >>Showers and thunderstorms will overspread the area from west to east this morning as our next storm system approaches.
More >>President Donald Trump says his personal attorney Michael Cohen represents him "with this crazy Stormy Daniels deal" and that "from what I see he did absolutely nothing wrong."
More >>President Donald Trump says his personal attorney Michael Cohen represents him "with this crazy Stormy Daniels deal" and that "from what I see he did absolutely nothing wrong."
More >>